Mattioli's Pizza Menu (Update 2026)

Mattioli's Pizza offers an extensive menu that champions Italian cuisine. Expect to find 79 delectable items, each crafted with fresh ingredients. Highlights include Burrata & Prosciutto, Sautéed Calamari, and their renowned Brick Oven Pizzas. The Prosciutto and Arugula Pizza stands out as a crowd favorite, showcasing perfectly paired flavors. For a lighter option, the Arugula Salad and Tuscan Artichoke Salad cater to those seeking freshness with every bite. With an average price of $15.76 for main dishes and an inviting lunch selection at $16.11, there's something for everyone. Providing an array of 217 dishes means endless opportunities to explore Italian fare.

Mattioli's Pizza Menu image 1
Mattioli's Pizza Menu image 2
Mattioli's Pizza Menu image 3

Featured Dishes

Martini
Martini
Prosciutto & Arugula Pizza
Prosciutto & Arugula Pizza
Mattioli's Pizza

Mattioli's Pizza Interior, Food, Ambiance

Walking into Mattioli's Pizza, the ambiance strikes as both cozy and upscale, reminiscent of a traditional speakeasy. The warm brick walls and soft lighting set an inviting tone for date nights or casual gatherings alike. The dining area feels intimate while accommodating various group sizes, making it a popular spot for couples and families. Food decoratively plated adds to the overall experience, enhancing the enjoyment of every dish. From the elegant presentation of the Caprese Salad to the hearty classic pizzas, each meal becomes a visual and culinary delight. The blend of a charming interior and delicious food makes Mattioli's a standout in the local dining scene.

Mattioli's Pizza

About Mattioli's Pizza Food and Specialties

Mattioli's Pizza specializes in authentic Neapolitan pizzas that bring the taste of Italy to Cuyahoga Falls. Each pizza, cooked to perfection in a brick oven, delivers a crispy crust and a unique flavor profile. The menu also boasts tantalizing antipasti options, like the Antipasto and Stuffed Peppers. Pair these small plates with a signature cocktail or a local beer for the complete experience. Regulars rave about the Mushroom Chicken Alfredo, making it a must-try. Seasonal offers like the Alani Cherry Slushie add a local twist to classic Italian dining, even appealing to those looking for a refreshing treat. Mattioli's caters not just to pizza lovers but to anyone craving Italian comfort food.

Mattioli's Pizza

Mattioli's Pizza is committed to quality and authenticity in every dish prepared. The restaurant prioritizes using fresh, locally sourced ingredients, ensuring that each bite bursts with flavor. This commitment extends to their specialty pizzas, like the prosciutto and arugula, which reflect traditional Italian recipes with a Cuyahoga Falls twist. The vision for Mattioli's is clear: create a space where exquisite food, community interaction, and vibrant ambiance come together. They continually innovate their menu, often introducing seasonal dishes that highlight diverse ingredients.

This approach not only keeps customers coming back for more but also strengthens ties to the local community. The restaurant aims to be a staple in the area, where friends and families can celebrate both the ordinary and the special moments of life.