Mattioli's Pizza

Discover Mattioli's Pizza in Cuyahoga Falls for authentic Italian flavors, featuring Neapolitan pizza, prosciutto and arugula, and creative cocktails. Experience our cozy speakeasy vibe, brick oven dishes, and perfect spot for couples. Call +1 330-810-1551 today!

Welcome to Mattioli's Pizza

Signature Dining Experience

Mattioli's Pizza
Mattioli's Pizza
Mattioli's Pizza
Mattioli's Pizza

Nestled in the heart of Cuyahoga Falls, Mattioli's Pizza delights both locals and visitors with its unique blend of traditional Italian flavors and a cozy ambiance. This pizzeria combines the art of pizza making with quality ingredients, offering an inviting escape for those craving Neapolitan-style pies. The decor resembles a speakeasy, providing an intimate setting perfect for couples and gatherings.

Located at 1846 Front St Suite G, this hidden gem draws food lovers eager to experience authentic Italian cuisine coupled with exceptional service. Whether you're in the mood for prosciutto and arugula pizza or a creamy mushroom chicken alfredo, Mattioli's Pizza guarantees satisfaction while delivering an unforgettable dining experience.

Location & Contact

Address

1846 Front St Suite G, Cuyahoga Falls, OH 44221, United States

Phone

+1 330-810-1551

About

Mattioli's Pizza
Mattioli's Pizza
Mattioli's Pizza
Mattioli's Pizza

Mattioli's Pizza prides itself on blending tradition with innovation, creating a dining experience that resonates well with its patrons. Founded in Cuyahoga Falls, this Italian eatery captures the spirit of Italy through its authentic dishes and culinary expertise. The highlight of Mattioli's is undoubtedly its Neapolitan pizza, celebrated for its hand-tossed dough and high-quality toppings. Each pizza is carefully baked in a brick oven, resulting in a flavorful crust that customers rave about. Besides pizza, the menu offers a variety of Italian delicacies, including tantalizing appetizers like bruschetta and antipasto, and hearty entrees such as mouth-watering chicken alfredo and savory stuffed peppers.

Mattioli's understands the pulse of the community, drawing in crowds during peak times, especially on Mondays and Saturdays at dinner.

Understanding when to visit can enhance your experience; for a quieter meal, aim for late Monday evenings or anytime on a Tuesday. With 79 menu items and prices that average just under $21, Mattioli's delivers value without compromising quality.

The restaurant does more than just serve food; it fosters a community spirit. Customers often enjoy the sense of camaraderie that comes from dining in a place where everyone seems to know one another. It's not uncommon to see friendly exchanges between staff and patrons, emphasizing hospitality as a core value. Whether celebrating a special occasion or just stopping in for a late-night bite, Mattioli's Pizza embodies the essence of local dining done right.

Work Hours

  • Sunday11 AM-10 PM
  • Monday11 AM-11 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-11 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-11 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-11 PM
  • Friday11 AM-12 AM
  • Saturday11 AM-12 AM

Mattioli's Pizza stands out with its brick oven baking, producing perfectly charred crust that's both crispy and chewy. Emphasizing fresh ingredients, the menu features a variety of pizzas, pastas, and salads that cater to diverse palates. Signature dishes include the burrata & prosciutto, sautéed calamari, and stuffed peppers, each meticulously crafted to tantalize your taste buds. With a price point averaging $20.75, diners enjoy high-quality meals without breaking the bank.

Another attractive feature is the extensive drink menu, boasting craft beers, a selection of wines, and refreshing cocktails like the Alani Cherry Slushie. The establishment also promotes a vibrant community atmosphere, perfect for families or date nights. Regulars appreciate the seasonal offerings that keep the menu fresh and exciting.

Mattioli's Pizza

Mattioli's Pizza boasts an unassuming yet charming exterior that invites passersby to step inside. The façade features warm brick accents and soft, ambient lighting, hinting at the welcoming atmosphere within. The outdoor seating area allows diners to enjoy their meals al fresco, perfect for soaking up the local vibe, especially during pleasant Ohio evenings. Large windows let in natural light, creating a bright space that enhances the cozy interior. Patrons often remark on the relaxed yet lively vibe, making it an excellent spot to gather with friends or enjoy a romantic dinner.

Customer Reviews

OMG! (Dios mio!!) guys and girls this is the new pizza spot! It's legit: I worked in Bronx , Brooklyn, queens, Chicago and live and work in Ohio , I can tell you this is awesome: just keep in mind when events /sporting/college stuff happening it's going to get busy. Could take a while. That is what has a few negative reviews. That's the way awesome pizza joints are. Pepperoni Pizza I added black olives mushroom, Cheese Pizza I added sausage mushroom, I ordered door dash and they had the pizza ready 6 -8 minutes that's Italian Neapolitan style. Driver grabbed it and in my hands 10 minutes. Amazing!!! Great talented team of people ! Can't wait to try other menu items . Thanks !!

C
Christopher B.

This place was awesome! I took my son there last night. The wood fired brick oven pizza was amazing and I feel like it's something this area was missing. The meatballs were just like my Italian grandmother used to make "seriously they were the identical". The coolest part is it's a speakeasy so you enter through a hidden door in a pop machine. The atmosphere was a really cool speakeasy vibe they had Leather seats, brass tables, every kind of alcohol and drink you can think of and really kind and attentive staff. You could dress up really nice for that high end date night feeling or you could just pop in casually dressed for some drinks or pizza. This place is a really cool addition to Cuyahoga Falls and I hope it becomes a staple. Also the prices were really decent.

B
Big T.

I went into going here with a bit of bias and an family discount due to my cousin however the pizza was amazingly tasty, the service was great I was able to make a custom pizza and basically made a delicious chicken pesto pizza with the chef even coming out and asking me if he got it right. ONE THING I will say is it is pricey and I did get a discount as I said but price is worth it for the food. Overall whenever I visit I will be coming back here and dining in maybe take out as well!

L
Luca C.

Been wanting to try and I ordered a pepperoni for delivery. Was blown away with how good it was! Nice thin crust that's fully cooked and the cheese is perfectly melted. Will definitely order again!!

S
Steve

I went here after a night in the city... The pizza was so good, I drove 30 minutes the next day for another one!! Very good pizza... Wood brick oven flavor, fresh ingredients, unique recipe flavor on the sauce. Excellent!

R
Randy T.

We got the Neapolitan pizza and really enjoyed it! It had plenty of cheese, not too much sauce, and the crust has a good flavor. We'll definitely be back to try other dishes and pizzas

L
Liv P.